Notes

Nobody publishes a method

Eleven pages that publish roofing sales commission figures were read on 9 November 2026. Not one of them states a survey, a sample size, or a set of companies behind its percentages. The numbers people quote to each other at trade shows come from nine publishers, six of whom have something to sell to the person reading the number, and three of whom say in their own words that their figures are examples rather than benchmarks.

Written by JD Davenport, who still sells for a living. Updated 16 November 2026.

That is the whole finding. The percentages are not wrong. They were never measurements.

What was counted

Nine commercial pages and two government pages, read at source on 9 November 2026. The commercial publishers are Contractors Cloud, Sequifi, GhostRep, The Roofing Brief, Roofing Salesman, IdealRev, Hook Agency with two pages, and ZipRecruiter. The government pages are the Bureau of Labor Statistics handbook entries for roofers and for wholesale and manufacturing sales representatives.

Every figure below was read on the page itself. Nothing here is averaged, smoothed, or carried over from a source that was quoting somebody else.

What I expected to find, and did not

I expected most published figures to state a percentage without saying percent of what. That is the argument this site made in how much commission a roofing salesman makes, and it is wrong as a description of the published record. That page has been corrected to say so.

Every commission rate on those nine pages names a base. Percent of contract, percent of gross profit, percent of collected revenue, percent of company gross income. Two figures in the whole set leave the base unstated. The record is better than I said it was.

The gap is one level down. Naming a base and defining it are two different acts, and almost nobody performs the second.

Naming is not defining

Two of the nine commercial pages say which costs come out before the percentage is applied. Sequifi defines gross profit as contract price minus direct job costs. GhostRep names the cost lines it means: materials, labor, permits, disposal. A third, The Roofing Brief, defines the pool for one model and leaves its other figure undefined.

The remaining six name a base and never say what is in it. "Thirty percent of gross profit" is not a rate until somebody says whether gross profit carries the dumpster, the warranty reserve, the credit card fee, the callback, and the hour the production manager spent on the phone. Two companies can run the same published number and pay a thousand dollars apart on the same roof.

The same model, the same percentage, two different paychecks

Six of the nine pages publish a model called 10/50/50. Ten percent comes off the top for overhead, and what is left is split evenly between the rep and the company.

Five of them take the ten percent from contract value. One, IdealRev, takes it from gross profit.

Run a fifteen thousand dollar job that costs nine thousand to build. Taking ten percent of contract leaves $4,500 to split, and the rep is paid $2,250. Taking ten percent of gross profit removes $600 instead of $1,500, leaves $5,400 to split, and the rep is paid $2,700.

Same job. Same model name. Same percentage. Four hundred and fifty dollars apart, which is twenty percent of the rep's check. The difference is one word in a definition that four of the five sources do not write down.

Where the numbers actually come from

Six of the eight commercial publishers sell something to the contractor reading the figure. Contractors Cloud and Sequifi sell commission software. GhostRep sells sales coaching software. IdealRev places sales staff. Hook Agency sells marketing. Roofing Salesman sells sales training. The Roofing Brief is a trade publication carrying advertising. ZipRecruiter is a job board.

Three of them disclaim their own numbers. Sequifi says its rates are illustrations chosen to make the arithmetic easy to follow. GhostRep says its figures describe other authors' plans rather than a survey. Hook Agency says its rates are examples rather than industry averages. Those three are the most honest pages in the set, and the disclaimer is the part nobody quotes.

Two state where their numbers came from. GhostRep read other blogs, and says so, with dates and links. ZipRecruiter derives pay from job postings and third party data, and gives no sample size. Neither is a survey of pay plans.

The rest publish percentages with no stated origin at all.

One figure in the set came from observed data

Contractors Cloud publishes a breakdown of payout types across roughly nineteen hundred roofing companies on its platform: commissions 1,026, company overhead 494, draws 213, bonuses 92, flat fees 45.

That is the only figure in eleven pages drawn from watching what companies actually do. It deserves credit for existing, and it carries two things a reader needs.

The unit is setups, not companies. The page counts configured payout types. One company running two plans appears twice. Quoted downstream as "fifty-four percent of roofing companies pay commission," it would be wrong about what was counted.

The parts do not sum to the whole. Those five counts add to 1,870 against a stated base of about 1,900. Thirty setups sit in no published category. The page does not say what they are, and it states no time period for the snapshot. None of that makes the figure wrong. It makes it a figure you can only use if you repeat its denominator alongside it.

The government number does not exist

There is no federal occupation code for roofing sales. The Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes roofers, code 47-2181, at a median of $55,440 a year as of May 2025, and that page describes people who replace, repair and install roofs. It publishes wholesale and manufacturing sales representatives, code 41-4000, at a median of $76,460 a year as of May 2025, and that page never mentions roofing.

Neither one is a roofing sales seat. Anybody citing a government figure for what a roofing salesperson earns is citing one of those two and not saying which.

The handbook does say something useful about structure: most employers combine salary with commissions or bonuses. That is a statement about the shape of pay, from a body that surveys. It is not a percentage, because the survey does not collect one.

What was ruled out

That the figures disagree because the industry varies. They disagree because the bases are undefined. The 10/50/50 spread above is one model, one percentage, one job size, and the gap is entirely definitional.

That the sources are independent. Sequifi published a worked example on 2 October 2026 using an eighteen thousand dollar contract, $11,700 of costs and $6,300 of gross profit. GhostRep published the same three numbers ten days later without attributing them, while attributing three other sources with links. The corpus has fewer original observations in it than it has pages.

That one page contradicted another on Hook Agency's content. GhostRep attributes figures to a Hook Agency URL that is not the page I read. Both pages exist. There is no contradiction, and the figures attributed to Adam Bensman and Dallas Werner live on a third page I did not read. Recorded so nobody re-tests it.

That the salary aggregators are internally consistent. ZipRecruiter's roofing sales page prints a 25th percentile of $59,000 and a 75th of $95,500 in its text, while its own chart shows $58,000 and $92,900, and shows a median of $71,400 that appears nowhere in the text. The page states no sample size and never mentions commission, so whether the figure includes commission is unknown.

That a widely repeated regional claim reproduces. Roofing Salesman states that a Minnesota roof pays a salesperson two to four hundred dollars more than a Dallas roof at a ten percent rate, from contract ranges of $6,000 to $7,000 in Dallas and $8,000 to $10,000 in Minneapolis. At ten percent those ranges produce a gap between one hundred and four hundred dollars depending on which ends you pair. The published floor of two hundred matches only the low pair. The Dallas figure is also a replacement cost value and the Minneapolis figure is a new roof price, which are not the same quantity.

What to do with all of this

Stop asking what the industry pays. The industry has not been measured, and the people who publish the numbers mostly say so if you read far enough down.

Ask the three questions instead. Percent of what, and which costs are in it. Paid when. Calculated by whom, and out of which report.

A commission plan that answers those three in writing is worth more than any benchmark on this page, because it is the only one of them that can be audited. The rest of the argument is in what goes in a commission agreement and in whether to pay reps on revenue or profit.

Every figure above was read at its source on 9 November 2026 and is quoted as published. Where a page's arithmetic did not reproduce, that is noted rather than corrected. If one of these pages changes, this one will be wrong, and the date above is how you will know to check.